Boundaries and Rewards: Tips on Using CRAFT

An Allies in Recovery member is encountering difficulties with removing rewards and holding boundaries. They’re asking their loved one to leave when he’s drinking, but he simply refuses! In this post, we offer a little refresher on rewards – when to use them, and what kinds – as part of the Community Reinforcement and Family Training (CRAFT) approach that we teach you on Alliesinrecovery.net.

This question originally appeared on the alliesinrecovery.net member blog:

“What do you do when you are asking him to leave when he has been drinking – and he refuses to leave? We just sweep it under the rug and walk away from him!”

Glad you wrote in with this seemingly basic question! I feel as though you’re really on the right track here. With a few tweaks, I think we can get you even more clear and effective.

When removing rewards is mixed up with boundaries

From my point of view, your question touches both on the specifics of “removing rewards” à la CRAFT, and on boundaries – how to stick to a boundary you’ve laid down.

Reading your comment, I’m thinking, let’s figure out how to avoid this situation becoming habitual. You are trying to enforce a boundary and your loved one is ignoring you. This is not great for anyone if it keeps happening: your loved one will have less and less respect for your boundaries if you’re unable to really follow through with them, and you will end up feeling helpless, standing behind a boundary that’s not being respected.

Rewards — a review

Before we dig more into boundaries, allow me a moment to highlight the major points to keep in mind when considering how you use rewards.

* Remember, rewards are given in moments of non-use as opposed to use, defined as: 1) about to use (too late to turn them around), 2) using/high, or 3) withdrawing from use/hungover. *

We’re talking here about immediate rewards, given in the moment. In the example you’ve given, there are two rewards involved:

1)  Being able to stay under your roof (I suspect your love one does not see this as a desirable, which is an important quality for a reward to have. It has to be something they perceive as being pleasant. I wonder if your love one sees this as being your obligation to them and/or they have nowhere to go, so in their mind they actually can’t comply with the demand of leaving. This is also long-term, not immediate, thus more complicated to give or take away), and

2)  Your presence/company We could even consider that in the way things played out, there’s another reward, which is the “sweeping it under the rug” — in a sense, that’s your loved one earning another “point”.

Let’s review the characteristics of an appropriate reward: 

(For a full refresher of what an appropriate reward would be for your situation, an Allies in Recovery Membership offers access to eLearning Modules specific to these topics such as Segment 4 of Module 5: “My Loved One Isn’t Using Right Now, Now What?” entitled “Characteristics and Types of Rewards”)

  • the reward should be pleasing to your loved one (not necessarily what would make you happy);
  • the reward should be easy to give (within your budget, accessible, and especially, not something that’s disagreeable for you – don’t force yourself);
  • the reward should also be easy to take away (a pay-as-you-go phone perhaps);
  • try to give the reward immediately when you see the behavior you want to reinforce — timing is key;
  • ideally, choose a reward that meets the same need filled by their substance use.
  • removing rewards is not a punishment.

There are 4 kinds of rewards:

  1. Stuff (e.g., something you picked out for them that you saved for the right moment)
  2. A positive, encouraging comment (e.g., “I really appreciate your help with the dishes”)
  3. Non-verbal behaviors (e.g., eye-contact, a scrunch on the shoulder, other body language that says “I’m paying attention to you”)
  4. Activities (e.g., a walk together, a game, cooking a meal together, a meal out, massaging each other, etc.)

Removing rewards — a key CRAFT component

An Allies in Recovery Membership includes access to what we call “Key Observations” exercises which allow you to work through your personal circumstances.. For example, Key Observation Exercise #16: “What Is Rewarding to My Loved One?” gives you an opportunity to choose rewards that might work on your loved one and to add others as you come up with them.

Here are the 3 things CRAFT asks you to do if you see (or strongly suspect) that your loved one has been using:

1)  Remove rewards (some of the time this can be done subtly, without speaking, but other times it may require a short, neutral explanation, i.e.: “You’re welcome to use the car when you’re not using, but until then I’m holding onto the keys.”)

2)  Step away, disengage (Your presence is known, and predictable – and therefore, comforting – to your loved one. Even if you’re mad or lecturing! You are a reward to them.)

3)  Allow natural consequences to occur (the best way to know what the natural consequence to their use would be is to ask yourself: “If I didn’t step in here, how would the larger environment treat my loved one right now?” Our member site offers a video with Allies in Recovery Founder and CRAFT Expert, Dominique Simon-Levine, on the topic of natural consequences, as well as many posts on this topic and more in our member blog.

There is also a Part 2 of this series, “A Cheat Sheet on Boundaries” which takes a deeper dive into setting boundaries with your Loved One. This series can be fully accessed with a membership on our Allies in Recovery member blog site, alliesinrecovery.net.

We’re glad you wrote in, and we hope things are getting better as you use CRAFT in your situation.

We’re here to help.

If you’re an Allies member, check out the member site for our “10-day Challenge” to claim your reward of a FREE One-Day CRAFT Workshop – just for finishing half the modules.

If you’re not yet a member of Allies in Recovery but want to join us TODAY to get trained on how to reduce the chaos of addiction in your familyclick here.

A membership at AlliesinRecovery.net brings you into contact with experts in CRAFT – the proven, most successful method for getting your loved one into recovery. Our unique, award-winning learning platform teaches you CRAFT, so you can play an important role in the recovery journey. With Allies, you’ll get information critical to understanding your loved one’s alcohol/drug addiction; you’ll learn the strategies and skills you need to engage your loved one onto the path to recovery; and you’ll get guidance on how to identify and cope with the flood of emotions you are feeling – because when you are coping better, you can better help your loved one.

Together we will move your loved one towards recovery.

Have a family member with a substance use disorder?

Become a member of Allies in Recovery and we’ll teach you how to intervene, communicate and guide your loved one toward treatment.

Related Posts from "CRAFT 101"

Wishes & Dips

You’ve got tools — such as active listening, being curious and open. So, when your loved one expresses what they would like, or feels they can’t continue as they are, you’re ready. In those moments of “wishes and dips,” you can gently move forward, listening to them and having resources ready, for now or whenever they’re ready. It’s a main tenet of CRAFT — noticing the openings. It’s also a practice — something to stay with over time, so you have a chance to be received.

Wishes & Dips

You’ve got tools — active listening, being curious and open. So, when your loved one expresses what they would like, or feels they can’t continue as they are, you’re ready. In those moments of “wishes and dips,” you can gently move forward, listening to them and having resources ready, for now or whenever they’re ready. It’s a main tenet of CRAFT — noticing the openings. It’s also a practice — something to stay with over time, so you have a chance to be received.

“Heads Up” Tips for Those New to Substance Use Disorder (SUD)

Have you ever looked back on a particularly stressful time in your life and wished you’d known a few things ahead of the struggle? Or maybe you were offered some “heads up” advice when enduring a hard time and found that the advice you received drastically empowered you through the situation. This blog shares some helpful tips for parents and other family members who are new to facing the crisis of addiction, alcoholism or Substance Use Disorder (referred to as “SUD”) with a loved one.

In-Person & Virtual Recovery Resources for Your Loved One

ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS (AA World Services, Inc.) Alcoholics Anonymous is a fellowship of men and women who share their experience, strength and hope with each other, that they may solve their common problem and help others to recover from alcoholism. This is an informational website for anyone interested in learning more about their organization, 12-step program of recovery, and how to find local meetings. PHONE: 212.870.3400 Click here for Online AA Meetings What is AA? What to Expect in an AA Meeting  What is Anonymity in AA?  AA INTERGROUP ONLINE MEETING FINDER IN THE ROOMS In The Rooms offers over 150+ weekly live online meetings, a variety 12-Step and Non-12- Step Fellowships, and Specialty meetings. Some of our most popular meetings are AA, NA, ACA, Al-Anon, and Nar-Anon meetings, and much more. In The Rooms has 69 live online AA meetings weekly, so there’s bound to be one that fits your schedule! We have specialty AA meetings too, like AA Pride (LGBTQ). We also have an Agnostic AA meeting, if you’re seeking a meeting without a secular approach to recovery. We have 30 NA meetings on ITR weekly. Like AA, there’s also an NA Pride meeting (LGBTQ) and an Agnostic NA meeting. For support for the family, friends, and allies of those in recovery, In The Rooms has both Al-Anon and Nar-Anon meetings, which each meeting, 1-3 times a week. We also have many other 12-step fellowship groups, like Gamblers Anonymous, Overeaters Anonymous, and Sex Addicts Anonymous, CODA, Dual Diagnosis, and much more. If you can think of a Recovery fellowship, we probably have it.  FULL LISTING of LIVE VIRTUAL/ONLINE MEETINGS  12Step.Org We strive to provide information, tools, and resources for working a 12 Step program (or any program using 12 step principles for recovery) in as simple and effective way as possible. Online Meeting Calendar Online Video Meetings Phone Meetings Forums, Text Chats, and Email Meetings List RECOVERY DHARMA Recovery Dharma is a peer-led movement and community that is unified by our trust in the potential of each of us to recover and find freedom from the suffering of addiction. We believe that the traditional Buddhist teachings, often referred to as…

A CRAFT Approach To Verbal Abuse

Provided the abuse isn’t physical, CRAFT can be your guide to a constructive response to negative interactions. Physical safety should come first in all relationships. But even in the absence of physical violence, a Loved One’s verbal abuse can be painful and damaging. As with other complications surrounding substance use disorder, CRAFT offers a clear, straightforward, and proven approach to dealing with harmful talk from a Loved One. Allies’ Laurie MacDougall outlines the fundamentals.

He’s Relapsing – Are We Enabling Him? CRAFT and Encouraging Non-Use

A member of AlliesinRecovery.net wrote in to our “Pose a Question” blog with concerns about her son being stuck at home and struggling without his Suboxone program. Relapses continue to occur. His brother has thrown illicit drugs in the trash and insists that the family be stricter. The parents are feeling torn about whether they are enabling. Can the family be of any help? Read this blog for our insights on how applying CRAFT strategies and “encouraging non-use” through your actions in the face of your loved one’s substance use disorder can be helpful.

Coming Home

After any treatment, when someone is in early recovery, check your expectations. Your loved one is likely in a fragile state, uncomfortable, edgy, body wrecked after dependency, and dis-regulated physically and emotionally. On this episode of our podcast “Coming Up for Air”,  hosts Laurie MacDougall, Dominique Simon-Levine and Kayla Solomon talk about how this is a time of transition for your loved one and emphasize the value of maintaining realistic expectations. Be gentle, caring, and connected, not an inquisitor. Connection is key.

The CRAFT Approach: An Introduction From Verywellmind.com

Verywellmind is a health website that takes pride in its quality, professionally-reviewed information. In this article, they make it clear how the CRAFT approach differs from old-school “interventions,” and why its outcomes are so much better overall. This is also a great general overview of the CRAFT approach, hitting the highlights of the skills and resources you can access through Allies in Recovery.

Unsolicited Advice: Helpful or Hurtful?

On this episode of our podcast “Coming Up for Air”,  hosts Laurie MacDougall,  Dominique Simon-Levine and Kayla Solomon talk about unsolicited advice. It’s smart to avoid giving unsolicited advice. If you receive it, hold your ground, knowing that you’re dedicated to upholding the CRAFT model. Consider telling the advice-giver to look into CRAFT to understand what you’re doing.

An Interview with Meme English

Guest Meme English, a former family therapist and consultant in the legal system, discusses family dynamics with hosts Kayla and Laurie. When it comes to substance use, family dynamics are complicated. There are many layers of trauma, from generational to personal, and competing needs among family members. Balancing all these factors and personal situations means deciding whose needs get most clearly met.

Coming Home

After any treatment, when someone is in early recovery, check your expectations. Your loved one is likely in a fragile state, uncomfortable, edgy, body wrecked after dependency, and dis-regulated physically and emotionally. On this episode of our podcast “Coming Up for Air”,  hosts Laurie MacDougall, Dominique Simon-Levine and Kayla Solomon talk about how your loved one coming home is a time of transition and encourage listeners to have realistic expectations. Be gentle, caring, and connected, not an inquisitor. Connection is key.

Unsolicited Advice: Helpful or Hurtful?

On this episode of our podcast “Coming Up for Air”,  hosts Laurie MacDougall,  Dominique Simon-Levine and Kayla Solomon talk about unsolicited advice. It’s smart to avoid giving unsolicited advice. If you receive it, hold your ground, knowing that you’re dedicated to upholding the CRAFT model. Consider telling the advice-giver to look into CRAFT to understand what you’re doing.

An Interview with Meme English

Guest Meme English, a former family therapist and consultant in the legal system, discusses family dynamics with hosts Kayla and Laurie. When it comes to substance use, family dynamics are complicated. There are many layers of trauma, from generational to personal, and competing needs among family members. Balancing all these factors and personal situations means deciding whose needs get most clearly met. Trauma therapy also requires time and commitment, and is harder to find since the pandemic.

The Discussion Blog on the Allies Website: Excerpts From One Member’s Journey

An important component of any member’s successful journey on the Allies website is participation in the expertly-moderated Discussion Blog. There, CRAFT/AIR trained staff interact with members by answering questions in both regular replies and in full, expert blog response posts offering guidance that any member can access. Members see other members sharing questions, frustrations, and successes similar to theirs, and also they often see how the Learning Modules are effectively used as referenced by our team experts and by members. We also offer dozens of supplementary podcasts by members of our Allied Team, discussing real situations with Loved Ones and using the CRAFT approach.

Podcast #80 — Low-Hanging Fruit: As the Family, What Actions Can You Take Today?

This episode focuses on "Low-Hanging Fruit," meaning: Give yourself some easy-to-accomplish, satisfying tasks that you can do today, to help move the situation forward with your Loved One.  You absolutely can help to move things forward. There absolutely are action items that you can do TODAY. And you absolutely can influence your Loved One in the direction of treatment and recovery. Science has shown this to be true. Listen in!

A Refresher on Removing Rewards

Giving and removing rewards is one of the key tenets of CRAFT. But rewards are easier when your dog earns a treat by doing something you asked them to do! Humans are complex. Rewarding, a concept borrowed from behaviorism, is proven to work, but there's a science to it. Read up and see if you're on the right track… 

Podcast #68 — How Do Alanon / Naranon Differ from CRAFT? An In-depth Comparison

(1 hour 1 min) Listen to this in-depth discussion on the differences, and a few similarities, between CRAFT and Alanon/Naranon. Which approach discourages continued interaction with your LO? Which one encourages you to reflect upon both the family member's role and the LO's behaviors? Which one gives you a toolkit for staying in touch and building a bridge with your LO? You can't afford not to listen to this episode!

I Feel Like I’ve Failed Her

Does it feel like you’ve given years of your life battling your Loved One’s addiction? Have you spent endless energy helping them and making things better for their kids? Do you feel like you’ve failed as a parent or grandparent? Here, Dominique Simon-Levine writes about caring for your Loved One’s kids and following a new light when everything seems lost.