Become a member of Allies in Recovery and we’ll teach you how to intervene, communicate and guide your loved one toward treatment.Become a member of Allies in Recovery today.

When Setting a Boundary Is the Message We Need to Send

Photo credit: Leonor Faria

Introduction CRAFT teaches us to be thoughtful, caring, and deliberate in the messages we send to our Loved Ones. But sometimes the message is best conveyed without words. When we set boundaries, we also have to help our Loved Ones understand that they’re for real. As Allies writer Laurie MacDougall discusses with Adrexpert, managing our own thoughts and feelings is a necessary precursor to this sort of work, and so much else.

My daughter called my husband yesterday and the conversation ratcheted up sentence by sentence. She insists that he’s siding with her husband in their divorce. She pressed the hot button, saying, “No one recovers without family support. All the messages you send mean nothing. Financial support, money, is what you owe me.” When she started cursing, he said he had to get off.

Today he wants to write to her, “You don’t want to live like this forever. I’ll be here to support you when you’re ready to make a change. I love you.”

Is this the most effective reply? What else can we do?

Hi Adrexpert,

I can feel the stress, frustration, and exasperation with these types of phone calls. We spend all our time worried and hoping with all our being that our Loved Ones (LOs) with addiction will show signs that they are taking even baby steps towards a better life—only to be discouraged when, once again, there’s no indication that they are. And to have our LOs hurl accusations and blame at us can lead to feelings of desperation and devastation, as well as uncertainty as to whether we’re doing the right thing. We certainly were not born with the skills to deal with something so challenging.

So, we have to develop those coping skills.

Pushing emotional buttons is a tactic that may have worked in the past for your daughter to get what she wanted. She is not comfortable in her situation, and she of course would prefer the easiest path to feeling better. That path may especially include something that

has worked in the past, something tried and true, so she can use or live her life in a way that is conducive to using, and feel better immediately.

First, let’s direct your attention to the positives in your husband’s response to your daughter. As soon as she started “pushing buttons”—saying that no one recovers without family support, that financial support is what Dad owes her, cursing—he got off the phone! Not an easy feat, but he did it.

Slowing down our own runaway trains

And why is it not easy? Well, Dad’s left with all of his own ruminating thoughts, anxieties, and fears after hanging up. Dealing with the whirlwind and chaos of our thoughts and feelings after an interaction with our LO is by far the MOST difficult thing when it comes to coping with their addiction.

What are some of the methods he’s using to help settle his own challenging thoughts and feelings? What does he do for himself once he hangs up that phone?

Calming your own system down and learning to emotionally regulate is quite a daunting task. But it is so critical in helping you to bring your best self to the table for both you and your LO. I wonder if your husband is giving himself time and space to engage in some sort of self-care. It might make it easier to continue to set down boundaries confidently with future calls.

Self-care is so difficult to practice. At the same time, it is so critical to healing for both Dad and his daughter. When we respond quickly, we’re often still grappling with our own intense emotions and thoughts. I would encourage him to take a break, press pause, and find ways to manage his internal strife first. Then, if he still wants to write her a letter, he can, but in a state less likely to be driven by mixed or confused emotions. By taking care of himself, he can work on a more calm and levelheaded approach.

Don’t overlook what he’s bringing to the emotional table

I suspect there are a few reasons that brought this interaction to an emotionally charged end: 1) the hope and anticipation that your daughter might be respectful and not try and manipulate Dad on this call for a change, 2) hopes that this might be the call in which she would ask for the kind of help he believes she needs, 3) feelings of guilt and other emotions triggered by the daughter’s comments, 4) the fact that your daughter wasn’t able to convince Dad to agree to her demands, and 5) the emotionally distraught and worked-up state she came to the call with, driving her to push buttons to get a response from Dad. There is frustration and disappointment for both parties. She isn’t doing what Dad was hoping for, and Dad isn’t doing what your daughter was hoping for.

We often look to the other person’s behavior as a way to soothe ourselves (even if we’re not aware that we’re doing so). But managing our thoughts and feelings is our responsibility.

Our feelings are ours to sort through and soothe, just as our LOs thoughts and feelings are theirs. Pressing the pause button by hanging up the phone gives Dad the opportunity to work on calming his thoughts and emotions.

Amy Morin, LCSW and bestselling author (dubbed “the self-help guru of the moment” by the Guardian), recently made a post on Instagram listing seven things to do when you feel intense emotions. The list really spoke to me:

  1. Name your feelings.
  2. Decide if your emotions are helpful or unhelpful.
  3. Let yourself feel uncomfortable.
  4. Reframe unhelpful thoughts.
  5. Experiment with healthy coping skills.
  6. Distract yourself.
  7. Act contrary to how you feel.

What about Dad practicing these steps when he ends the conversation with his daughter until his thoughts and emotions settle down?

Maybe, while on the next call with his daughter, he could consider not having any expectations of her. Let the conversation be only about touching base or checking in. If she has another agenda for the call, he could state what he is willing to offer. If she continues to press and starts in with triggering comments and requests, he ends the conversation. Just repeat what he has already done and work on making his boundary clear. By doing this he is:

  1. Creating a boundary. He is not going to be the whipping post for your daughter when he isn’t giving in to what she wants.
  2. Giving himself space to manage his own thoughts and feelings.
  3. Giving your daughter space to learn to handle her own challenging thoughts and feelings, and letting her find her own solutions to her problems regardless of what those solutions are.
  4. Giving himself time and space to prepare for the next call and what his response will be.
  5. Modeling for his daughter how to handle difficult thoughts and feelings as an adult.
  6. Empowering himself by not allowing his daughter to continue to hurt him, and sending the message to her that he won’t accept this behavior.
  7. Empowering his daughter by sending the message that he believes she can learn to interact with him and others in an acceptable way and deal with her own emotions and feelings.

And so much more.

At the same time, for a few reasons, your husband might want to reconsider writing your daughter that letter. If he sends the letter, it minimizes the impact of the action that he has already taken (setting that boundary, hanging up the phone). Writing a response can send an implicit message to your daughter that he is feeling unsure about his choices. Not writing a response letter sends the message that he is confident in setting up his boundary. There can be conversation when there is mutual respect, and as soon as he starts to feel the pangs of a conversation headed towards battle, that’s his limit. And it ends.

Sending a letter also reveals that he has an agenda when speaking with his daughter. It actually draws attention away from her difficult behavior, the blaming, shaming, and guilting of Dad.

Instead of writing a letter, what if Dad just continues to do what he did with this call? He sets down a boundary. He will not engage when she is saying hurtful things. It might sound something like:

I can the hear frustration in your voice, and I can feel my own frustration rising. I need some space from the conversation to deal with what I am going through. I’m not going to be good in this conversation. We can talk later, at a better time. Call me in a couple of days if you’re up for a talk.

Now I know she may quickly start in on Dad with accusations and attempts to make him feel bad for ending the conversation, but stick to it and hang up the phone. Just a quick response like, “Talk to you later.” And hang up.

Ending a hurtful conversation can convey your trust that she’s capable of better

She may be left with her own frustrations because what she’s used to doing is now not working. But it’s OK for her to start learning how to deal with this. Taking a calm approach sends the message that Dad believes she can handle things in the end. This may be the start of letting her be accountable for her behavior and learning that her behavior affects others.

Lastly, I would encourage Dad to steer away from comments like, “I’ll be here to support you when you’re ready to make a change.” I suspect that this conversation has happened many times. She already knows. If she brings up her needs outside of what has been offered, his response could be, “This is what I can offer…” or “You already know what I am willing to offer, and I’m sticking with that” or “Nevertheless, Mom and I have decided what we are willing to do, and that’s it.” If she starts pushing, get off the phone. Don’t be dragged into a back-and-forth of triggering comments meant to elicit a particular response from Dad and justifications by Dad for why he’s making the choices he’s making. Let the actions do the talking.

Keep trying to set this boundary. Practice, practice, practice. It may take a few tries, but there absolutely is potential for the situation (and those high-pressure calls) to change for the better. If she is well enough to learn to use these strategies to get Dad to do what she wants, she is also well enough to unlearn this behavior and learn better ways to interact with him.

Kudos to Dad. What he did by hanging up was in no way easy. I would encourage him to continue to hold to that boundary while finding ways to manage his own feelings. Stick with it. Over time, he can build his confidence with CRAFT skills.

Please keep us updated. We wish you, your husband, and your daughter all the best.

Laurie MacDougall

Loading

Related Posts from "Discussion Blog"

What Do We Have to Look Forward To?

Supporting a Loved one with SUD means different things to different people. Meggie, for example, comes from a family that’s confronted the disorder through “tough love”—leaving the Loved One to deal with their addiction entirely alone. This never felt right to Meggie, who wanted to fight alongside her husband for his recovery. When she discovered CRAFT, she soon realized it was designed to help her do just that. Nonetheless, thoughts of the future still leave her anxious. What if he’s in and out of jail for a long time to come? Isabel Cooney reminds us that so much depends on what we tell ourselves about both the present and the possible future.

Straight to Treatment After Jail? Do I Stick to My Guns?

Sometimes we can see the likely future: our Loved One returns to the shelter of home, hides away in their room, and simply doesn’t get the treatment they need to make progress with their SUD. Allies’ member HelenBo doesn’t want to see that happen with her son, who is struggling with heroin and other substances. What other housing options will he have upon release? As Laurie MacDougall writes, there are often more than we realize. At the same time, such transitions are critical moments for our Loved Ones. Having a list of specific housing and treatment options at hand—along with the CRAFT skills to communicate about them effectively—can make all the difference.

Cutting Him Off Entirely Isn’t the Answer—Is It?

We’ve all heard the argument: cut the cord. Let them sink to rock bottom. They’ve made their bed; now they have to lie in it. Recently, Allies member erinlewis was offered this sort of advice concerning her teenage son. Data and experience have shown that such an approach is usually the wrong one for our Loved Ones—but maintaining a connection doesn’t mean that anything goes. Laurie MacDougall walks us through a CRAFT-informed approach to self-care, boundaries, and the balancing act of connection and accountability.

When Stepping Back Is the Best Help You Can Give

No one wants a Loved One to suffer. No one wants a Loved One to relapse. But in our worry about such possibilities, we can stumble into behaviors that stand in the way of change—behaviors that make problematic substance use easier for our Loved Ones than it otherwise would be. Fortunately, CRAFT can help us learn to offer support within our chosen boundaries: the kind of support that truly encourages progress.

About This Whole “Engage When They’re Not Using” Business…

If you’ve worked your way through Allies’ eLearning Modules, you’re already familiar with the concept: when our Loved One (LO) is using, we remove rewards and allow for natural consequences. When they’re not using, we reward them right away. But as member BRIGHTSIDE has been finding, the real-life timing can be a challenge. Laurie MacDougall reviews the fundamentals of this process, and shares ideas for getting creative when the lines seem blurred.

What Is Our Role? Underlying Feelings and Beliefs We Have About Our Loved Ones

Like many of us who have Loved Ones struggling with SUD, Allies member Binnie knows that trust is a delicate matter. Can we trust our Loved Ones to take care of themselves? Do we believe they have the capacity? Or do we think they’re so damaged that they can’t function without our stepping in? Isabel Cooney reflects on how trust is explored in a recent Allies podcast, and offers her own insightful take on this vital subject.

Evidence From Oregon: Decriminalizing Drugs Can’t Solve Every Problem, but It’s an Important Step All the Same

Oregon has just rescinded Measure 110, the historic law that decriminalized possession of small amounts of hard drugs. But the reasoning behind the rollback is muddled. As guest author Christina Dent reveals, M110 took the blame for spikes in lethal overdoses, homelessness, and public drug use, none of which it likely caused. Rather, she argues that the law represented a small but important step forward. In the effort to end the drug crisis, its repeal is a loss.

Getting the Most Out of This Site

Personal trainers and the like are terrific—when they’re accessible. Unfortunately, individual counseling is still a rarity with CRAFT, despite its proven effectiveness. Allies in Recovery was created to bridge that gap. In this post, founder and CEO Dominique Simon-Levine outlines the many forms of training, education, and guidance that we offer on this website. We hope it helps you find the support you need.

What We Can and Can’t Control: It’s Good to Know the Difference

Erica2727 has a husband who’s working hard on his recovery, but his place of work concerns her. She would like him to consider various options, but isn’t sure about how to talk over such matters with him. Allies’ writer Laurie MacDougall offers a guide to a vital distinction: on the one hand, what we can and should seek to control; and on the other, what we cannot, and don’t need to burden ourselves with attempting.

How I Boiled Down CRAFT for My Teenage Kids

What can our children make of CRAFT? Allies’ writer Isabel Cooney has a powerful story to share—and some great thoughts for our community about opening a little window on the practice. As her experience suggests, CRAFT may have more to offer than a child or teen can truly take on. But young people may still benefit from an introduction to what the adults in their lives are trying to do.

Progress and Appreciation: A Letter From Holland

Danielle and her son have gone through a lot, individually and together. At Allies, we remember their years of struggle relating to his SUD. What joy, then, to receive this letter updating us on their situation. It’s the best news imaginable: Danielle’s son is clean and stable, and Danielle herself has widened the circle of support to others in need. Have a look at Danielle’s letter for yourself:

She Wants Another Round of Rehab. Should I Open My Wallet Yet Again?

Member Klmaiuri’s daughter struggles with alcohol and cocaine use. She’s also been through rehab seven times. The cycle—use, treatment, partial recovery, return to use—can feel like a cycle that never ends. Is there a way to be supportive while put a (loving) wrench in the gears? Allies’ writer Laurie MacDougall says absolutely yes. But it takes a commitment to learning new skills, trying a new approach, and lots of practice.

“Get Me Out of Here!” Navigating Your Loved One’s Desire to Quit Treatment

This Discussion Blog post is a little different: a response to member Nohp’s question by way of a recent episode on our Coming Up For Air podcast. Nohp’s husband has struggled with alcohol for over a decade. Recently, when faced with the possibility of divorce, he entered a 30-day residential treatment program—and he doesn’t care for it much. After two weeks, he wants out. Nohp understands some of his concerns, but worries that he will start drinking again if he leaves. Our Allies podcast team has a message for her: Discomfort does not mean treatment is a mistake. Allies writer Isabel Cooney elaborates.

Welcome Home! Everyone Here Has Some Beef With You

Tradition is (at least partly) about honoring the past, and holiday traditions are no exception. But some aspects of the past we’d rather just leave there. Others, even years later, can still make us long for resolution. Last year, Allies writer Isabel Cooney received a request from her ex-husband, who struggles with alcohol use, to be with her, their daughters, and Isabel’s parents over Christmas. Her reply, and the experiences that followed, gave Isabel a chance to reflect on all that she’s learned and tried to apply concerning CRAFT.

How Much Should I Ask of Him Right Now?

Challenging emotions are natural, but that doesn’t make them easy to deal with. Our heavy feelings and ruminating thoughts can vastly complicate our efforts to support our Loved Ones. Allies’ member Nohp is trying to balance her husband’s treatment needs with feelings of guilt about past agreements between them. Laurie MacDougall offers some CRAFT-informed signposts through this forest of thought and feeling.

Tragedy Struck His Recovery House, And He Wants Out. What’s My Response?

It’s an all-too-familiar refrain: our Loved One doesn’t like the treatment program and wants out. Sometimes the reasons may seem valid, perhaps even overwhelming. In the recovery house where Cowgirl’s son is living, the house manager recently overdosed and died. The situation is utterly heartbreaking, but does it mean that Cowgirl’s son should leave? Allies Director Dominique Simon-Levine cautions that no choice about changing treatment is free of risk.

Handling the Holidays, Embracing Change

We’ve all felt the push-and-pull of the holidays. One impulse is to hold so tightly to “the way we do things” that we try to stop time in its tracks. Another, when the holidays produce stress or challenges for a Loved One, is to turn away completely. Laurie MacDougall reflects that there’s often a loving path between these extremes—but that path requires reflective listening, validating our Loved One’s feelings, and acceptance that some things will change.

I Want Him in Treatment. I’m Dreading That the Cycle Hasn’t Ended.

It’s a situation that occurs all too often: a Loved One enters detox when things get rough, but resists moving on from there to sustained treatment for substance use disorder. Often, they just want to come home—where continuing to use is easier than having to face the mountainous struggle of ending that use. It’s little wonder that such moments cause worry and anxiety. The good news is that we can take positive actions all the same. As Laurie MacDougall writes, these actions begin with calming and centering ourselves.

He’s Lost His License. And He’s Still Behind the Wheel.

Kathy4422 is facing some tough choices. Her son has just lost his license but is continuing to drive—on her insurance, in a car she owns. Does she step back and let him face the consequences of his choices? Does she intervene right away, and if so, how? Allies’ writer Laurie MacDougall points out that no one can make such decisions for us. But through seven thoughtful questions, she offers a guide to making them ourselves.

My Loved One’s Breaking Our Agreement About Use at Home. What Should I Do About It?

After time in a recovery house—and agreeing in writing not to use while living at home—Carolyn P.’s Loved One has moved in with her. Much has been going well, but now the accumulating signs leave little doubt: they’re using again. Carolyn P. has been working hard to apply CRAFT to her situation. She worries, though, that her “watchful silence” might be counterproductive. Laurie MacDougall brings her back to a key, if difficult, CRAFT fundamental: boundary setting.